마르크스의 추상노동에 관해

강남훈(1985), ｢우노꼬조(宇野弘藏)의 원리론에 대하여｣, 한신경제과학연구소 경제학토론 8504호
강남훈(1985), ｢크라우제(U.Krause)의 추상노동가치론｣, 한신경제과학연구소 경제학토론 8506호
강남훈(1986), ｢전형문제에 대한 재검토｣, 『가치이론』, 까치
강남훈(1986), ｢가치이론에 대한 베네티와 카르틀리에의 비판｣, 한신경제과학연구소 경제학토론 8602호
강남훈(1990), ｢가치와 생산가격 이론에 대한 연구｣, 서울대학교 경제학과 박사논문
강남훈(1990), ｢전형과정의 두단계: 리피에츠의 보완｣, 한국사회경제학회 발표논문집 9006
권영경(1992), ｢리카도에서 맑스의 가치론의 이행과정에 관한 연구 - 불변의 가치척도와 가치형태론을 중심으로 -｣, 연세대학교 경제학과 박사논문
류동민 外(1992), ｢가치론의 쟁점과 이론적 의의｣, 한국사회경제학회 제 6회 학술대회 발표논문집
이채언(1990), ｢가치개념의 새로운 확립을 위하여｣, 한국사회경제학회 연구논문집 9009
이채언(1993), ｢루빈 가치이론의 비판｣, 『춘계 박광순 박사 화갑기념논문집』
양희석(1992), ｢리카도의 불변가치척도와 맑스의 가치전형｣, 한국사회경제학회 연구논문집 9212
정운영(1993), 『노동가치론 연구』, 까치
허선주(1993), ｢‘異端的 接近’의 마르크스 가치이론에 대한 비판에 대한 연구｣, 서울대학교 경제학과 석사논문
홍 훈(1992), ｢가치형태론에 존재하는 한가지 이질성에 관한 연구｣, 한국사회경제학회 연구논문집 9207

[구미문헌]
Amin,S(1978), The Law of Value and Historical Materialism,[강희석 譯(1985), 『가치법칙과 사적유물론』, 민음사]
Amstrong,P, Glyn,A, Harrison,J(1978), In Defence of Value: A Reply to Ian Steedman, Capital and Class, 6.
Arthur,C.J(1979), Dialectic of the Value-Form, Value: The Presentation of Labor in Capitalism (Elson,D ed.), CSE Books
Arthur,C.J(1988), Hegel`s Theory of Value, Value, Social Form and the State (Williams,M ed.), Macmillan
Aumeeruddy,A & Tortajada,R(1979), Rereading Marx on Value: A Note on the Basic Texts, Value: The Presentation of Labor in Capitalism (Elson,D ed.), CSE Books
Banaji,J(1979), From the Commodity to Capital: Hegel`s Dialectic in Marx`s Capital, Value: The Presentation of Labor in Capitalism (Elson,D ed.), CSE Books
Bandyopadhyay,P(1981), Critique of Wright, The Value Controversy (Steedman,I and Sweezy,P & Others ed.), Verso
Bandyopadhyay,P(1984-5), Value and Post-Sraffa Marxian Analysis, Science and Society, winter
Beck,R(1979), Einige kritische Anmerkungen zu Lösungsversuchen für das Transformationsproblem, Beiträge zur Marxschen Theorie 13, Suhrkamp Verlag
Bettelheim,C(1975), Economic Calculation and Forms of Property, Monthly Review Press
Bidet,J(1983), Labor-Value as a Political Category, Rethinking Marx
Bidet,J(1985), Que Faire du ?, Librairie des Méridiens Klinksieck et Cie[日譯, 資本論をどう讀むか, 法政大學出版局]
Bidet,J(1986), Socialisation et abstraction: Lecture de l`ouvrage: <>, Cahiers D`économie Politique 12
Böhm-Bawerk(1985), ｢마르크스와 마르크스체계의 종언｣, 『노동가치론 논쟁』(이인호 編譯), 학민사
Bowles,S & Gintis,H(1977), The Marxian theory and heterogeneous labor: a critique and reformation, Cambridge Journal of Economics, 1
Bradby,B.(1982), The Remystification of Value, Capital and Class,
Carling,A(1984-5), Observation on the labor theory of value, Science and Society, winter
Carling,A(1986), Forms of Value and The Logic of Capital, Science and Society, spring.
Cartelier,J(1991), Marx`s theory of value, exchange and surplus value: a suggested reformulation, Cambridge Journal of Economics, 15
Chepurenko(1988)[김정로 譯(1989)], 『현대 ｢자본론｣ 논쟁』, 참한
Clarke,S.(1980), Thr Value of Value, Capital & Class, 10.
Clarke,S.(1989), The basic theory of capitalism: A critical review of Itoh and the Uno School, Capital and Class, 17
Cogoy,M(1979), Traditionalle und neue Arbeitswerttheorie, Beiträge zur Marxschen Theorie 13, Suhrkamp Verlag
Cohen,G.A(1981), The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept of Exploitation, The Value Controversy (Steedman,I and Sweezy,P & Others ed.), Verso
Colletti,L(1977), Some Comments on Marx`s Theory of Value, The Subtle Anotomy of Capitalism (Schwartz ed.), Goodyear Pub.
Collier,I.L(1986), On Marxian Value, Exploitation, and the Transformation Problem: A Geometric Approach, Journal of Comparative Economics, 10
Cutler,A., Hindess,B., Hirst,P., Hussain,A.(1977), Marx`s Capital and Capitalism Today (Vol One, Two), Routledge & Kegan Paul
de Brunhoff,S(1973), Marx as an a-Ricardian: value, money and price at the beginning of Capital, Economy and Society, 2(4)
Deleplace,G(1981), Théorie du Capitalisme, Presses Universitaires de Grenoble [일역: 池上 修 外 역(1988), 『｢政治經濟學｣とマルス主義』, 岩波書店]
Desai,M(1991), The Transformation problem, Marx and Modern Economic Analysis (G.A Cavale ed.), Edward Elgar.
Desai,M(1991), Methodological Problems in Quantitative Marxism, Quantitative Marxism(Dunne,P. ed.), Polity Press
Devine,J.(1989), What is simple labor?; A Re-examination of the value-creating capacity of skilled labour, Capital & Class
de Vroey,M(1981), Value, Production, and Exchange, The Value Controversy (Steedman,I and Sweezy,P & Others ed.), Verso
de Vroey,M(1982), On the Obsolescence of the Marxian Theory of Value: A Critical Review, Capital and Class, 17
de Vroey,M(1985), ｢마르크스주의 가치이론에 대한 추상노동적 해석: 하나의 비판적 평가｣(정운영 譯), 『가치이론』(1986), 까치
Duménil,G(1983-4), Beyond the Transformation Riddle: A Labor Theory of Value, Science and Society, 47(4)
Duménil,G & Lévy,D(1987), The Dynamics of Competetion: A Restoration of the Classical Analysis, Cambridge Journal of Economics 11
Ehbar,H & Glick,M(1986), The Labor Theory of Value and Its Critics, Science and Society, winter.
Eldred,M & Hanlon,M(1981), Reconstructing Value-Form Analysis, Capital and Class, 13.
Eldred,M(1984), Review on Krause,U(1982), Review of Radical Political Economics, fall.
Eldred,M(1985), A Reply to Gleicher, Capital and Class, 23
Elson,D(1979), The Value Theory of Labor, Value: The Presentation of Labor in Capitalism (Elson,D ed.), CSE Books
Farjourn,E(1984), The Production of Commodities by Means of What?, Ricardo, Marx, Sraffa(Mandel,E & Freeman,A ed.), Verso.
Farjoun,E & Machover,M(1983), Laws of Chaos, Verso
Farjoun,E & Machover,M(1985), Probability, Economics and the Labor Theory of Value, New Left Review
Fine,B & Harris,L(1979), Rereading Capital, The Macmillan Press[김수행 譯(1984), 『현대정치경제학입문』, 한울]
Fine,B(1982), Theories of the Capitalist Economy, Holmes & Meier Pub.
Fisher,N(1982), The Ontology of Abstract Labor, Review of Radical Political Economics, 14:2.
Flaschel,P(1979), Wert und Arbeitswert, Beiträge zur Marxschen Theorie 13, Suhrkamp Verlag
Foley,D.K(1982), The Value of Money, the Value of Labor Power and the Marxian Transformation Problem, Review of Radical Political Economics, 14(2)
Foley,D.K(1986), Understanding Capital: Marx`s Economic Theory, Harvard University Press
Freeman,A(1984), The Logic of the Transformation Problem, Ricardo, Marx, Sraffa(Mandel,E & Freeman,A ed.), Verso.
Ganssmann,H(1983), Marx Without the Labor Theory of Value?, Social Research, 50(2), (reprinted in Karl Marx`s Economics(Wood,J.,C. ed.))
Ganssmann,H(1988), Abstract labor as a metaphor? A comment on Steedman, History of Political Economics, 20:3
Gerstein,I(1976), Production, Circulation and Value, Economy and Society, 5(3)
Gintis,H & Bowles,S(1981), Structure amd Practice in the Labor Theory of Value, Review of Radical Political Economics, 12(4)
Gleicher,D(1983), A Historical Approach to the Question of Abstract Labor, Capital and Class, 21
Gleicher,D(1985), Note: a rejoinder to Eldred, Capital and Class, 24
Gleicher,D(1985), The Ontology of Labor Values, Science and Society, winter
Glick,M & Ehbar,H(1987), The Transformation Problem: An Obituary, Austrian Economic Papers, December.
Gouverneur,J(1983), Contemporary Capitalism and Marxist Economics, Martin Robertson
Hahn,J(1991), Transformationproblem und Werttheorie, Z - Nr.7
Hilferding,R(1975), Böhm-Bawerk`s Criticism of Marx, in Sweezy ed. Karl Marx and the Close of his System[이인호 譯(1985), ｢뵘바베르크의 마르크스 비판｣, 『노동가치론 논쟁』, 학민사]
Himmelweit,S & Mohun,S(1978), The Anomalies of Capital, Capital and Class, Autumn
Himmelweit,S & Mohun,S(1981), Real Abstraction and Anomalous Assumptions, The Value Controversy (Steedman,I and Sweezy,P & Others ed.), Verso
Himmelweit,S(198 ), Value Relations and Divisions within the Working Class, Science and Society
Hodgson,G(1974), Positive Profits with Negative Surplus Value, Journal of Economic Literature, 12.
Hodgson,G(1980), A Theory of Exploitation without the Labor Theory of Value, Science and Society,fall.
Hodgson,G(1981), Critique of Wright, The Value Controversy (Steedman,I and Sweezy,P & Others ed.), Verso
Howard,H(1983), Profits in Economic Theory, St. Martin`s Press
Howard,M.C(1987), Economics on a Sraffian Foundation: A Critical Analysis of Neo-Ricardian Theory, Economy and Society, 16(3).
Howard,M.C & King,J.E(1989), A History of Marxian Economics Vol I, Macmillan
Howard,M.C & King,J.E(1992), A History of Marxian Economics Vol II, Macmillan
Hussain,A(1979), Misreading Marx`s Theory of Value: Marx`s Marginal Notes on Wagner, Value: The Presentation of Labor in Capitalism (Elson,D ed.), CSE Books
Itoh,M(1979), Marx`s Theory of Market-Value, Value: The Presentation of Labor in Capitalism (Elson,D ed.), CSE Books
Itoh,M(1980), Value and Crisis: Essays on Marxian Economics in Japan, Pluto Press[김수행 譯(1988), 『가치와 공황』, 비봉]
Itoh,M(1981), Joint Production: The Issues after Steedman, The Value Controversy (Steedman,I and Sweezy,P & Others ed.), Verso
Itoh,M(1988), The Basic Theory of Capitalism, Macmillan
Itoh,M(1992), The Value Controversy Reconsidered, Radical Economics (Roberts,B & Feiner,S ed.), Kluwer Academic Pub.
Jahn,W(1991), Die Problemantinomie in der Entwicklung von Ware, Wert und Geld zwischen dem esoterischen und exoterischen Werk von Marx und die Folgen, Z - Nr.7
Kay,G(1979a), Why Labor is the starting point of Capital, Value: The Presentation of Labor in Capitalism (Elson,D ed.), CSE Books
Kay,G(1979b), The Economic Theory of the Working Class, MaCmillan
Kilman,A & McGlone,T(1988), The transformation non-problem and the non- transformation problem, Capital and Class, 35
Krause,U(1979), Elemente einer multisektoralen Analyse der Arbeit, Beiträge zur Marxschen Theorie 13, Suhrkamp Verlag
Krause,U(1982), Money and abstract labor, Verso.
Laibman,D(1980), Exploitation, Commodity Relations and Capitalism: A Diffence of the Labor-Value Formation, Science and Society
Langston,R(1984), A New Approach to the Relation Between Prices and Values, Ricardo, Marx, Sraffa(Mandel,E & Freeman,A ed.), Verso.
Lee,C.O.(1990), On the Three Problems of Abstraction, Reduction and Transformation in Marx`s Labor Theory of Value, LSE PhD.Dissertation
Lipietz,A(1982), The So-Called `Transformation Problem Revisited`, Journal of Economic Theory, 26
Lipietz,A(1985), The Enchanted World, Verso. [김균 譯(1993), 『조절이론과 마르크스 경제학의 재해석』, 인간사랑]
Lippi,M(1979), Value and Naturalism in Marx, NLB
Mandel,E(1971), Marxist Economic Theory Vol 1, Monthly Review Press
Mandel,E(1984), Intrduction, Ricardo, Marx, Sraffa(Mandel,E & Freeman,A ed.), Verso.
Mandel,E(1984), Gold, Money, and the Transformation Problem, Ricardo, Marx, Sraffa(Mandel,E & Freeman,A ed.), Verso.
Marx,K.(1963;1968;1971), Theories of Surplus Value, Vol 1,2,3, Progress Publisher.
Marx,K(1973), Introduction, Grundrisse(김호균 譯(1988), ｢정치경제학비판서설｣, 『정치경제학 비판을 위하여』, 중원문화)
Marx,K.(1987), ｢임금, 가격 및 이윤｣, 『경제학노트』(김호균 譯), 이론과 실천
Marx,K.(1988), 『정치경제학비판을 위하여』(김호균 譯), 중원문화
Marx,K.(1989a), 『자본론』, 1권(김수행 譯), (상)(하), 비봉출판사
Marx,K.(1989b), Marginal Notes on Adolph Wagner`s Lehrbuch der Politische Ökonomie, Collected Works Vol. 24, Progress Publishers
Marx,K.(1990a), 『자본론』, 2권(김수행 譯), 비봉출판사
Marx,K & Engels,F.(1990b), 『자본론에 관한 서한집』(김호균 譯), 중원문화
Marx,K.(1991), 『자본론』, 3권(김수행 譯), (상)(하), 비봉출판사
Meek,L.M(1985), 『노동가치론의 역사』(김제민 譯), 풀빛
Mohun,S(1983), Abstract Labor, Socially Necessary Labor, in Bottomore,B ed. A Dictionary of Marxist Thought, Harvard
Mohun,S(1984-5), Abstract Labor and its Value-Form, Science and Society, winter
Mohun,S(1991), The Context of the Transformation Problem, Quantitative Marxism (Dunne,P. ed.), Polity Press
Morishima,M(1973), Marx`s Economics, Cambridge University Press
Morishima,M(1975), The Fundamental Marxian Theorem: A Reply to Samuelson, Journal of Economic Literature 85
Nuti,D.M(1977), The Transformation of Labor Values into Production Prices and the Marxian Theory of Exploitation, The Subtle Anotomy of Capitalism (Schwartz ed.), Goodyear Pub.
Oakley,A(1976), Two Notes on Marx and the `Transformation`, Economica, 43
Oakley,A(1984), Marx`s Critique of Political Economy Vol 1, Routledge & Kegan Paul
Okishio,N(1963), A Mathematical Note on Marxian Theorems, Weltschaftliches Archives, Vol.91
Ochoa,E.M(1989), Values, prices, and wage-profit curves in the US economy, Cambridge Journal of Economics, 13
Picard,R(1979), Gibt es ein Transformationsproblem ? , Beiträge zur Marxschen Theorie 13, Suhrkamp Verlag
Pilling,G(1972), The Law of Value in Ricardo and Marx, Economy and Society,
Renkin,S(1987), Exploitation and the Labor Theory of Value: a neo-Marxian reply, Capital and Class, 32
Reuten,G(1988), Value as Social Form, Value, Social Form and the State (Williams,M ed.), Macmillan
Reuten,G & Williams,M(1989), Value-Form amd the State, Routledge
Romero,H.G, Marx, Sraffa, and Neo-classical in Context, Ricardo, Marx, Sraffa(Mandel,E & Freeman,A ed.), Verso.
Roberts,B(1987), Marx after Steedman: Separating Marxism from ‘Surplus Theory ’, Capital and Class, 32
Roncaglia,A(1978), Sraffa and the Theory of Prices, Wiley
Rowthorn,B(1980), Capitalism Conflict & Inflation, Lawrence amd Wishart
Rubin,I.I(1972), Essays on Marx`s Theory of Value, B & R [함상호 譯(1989), 『마르크스의 가치론』, 이론과 실천]
Rubin,I.I(1978), Abstract Labor and Value in Marx`s System, Capital and Class, 5.
Salama,P(1984), Value and Price of Production: A Differential Approach, Ricardo, Marx, Sraffa(Mandel,E & Freeman,A ed.), Verso.
Savran,S(1984), The Negation of `Negative Values`, Ricardo, Marx, Sraffa(Mandel,E & Freeman,A ed.), Verso.
Sekine,T.T(1980), The Nessecity of the Law of Value, Science and Society
Sekine,T.T(1984-5), An Uno School Seminar on the Theory of Value, Science and Society, winter
Sen,A.(1978), On the Labor Theory of Value: Some Methodological issues, Cambridge Journal of Economics, 2.
Shaikh,A(1977), Marx`s Theory of Value and the `Transformation Problem`, The Subtle Anotomy of Capitalism (Schwartz ed.), Goodyear Pub.
Shaikh,A(1979), Foreign Trade and the Law of Value: Part I, Science and Society, fall
Shaikh,A(1980), Foreign Trade and the Law of Value: Part II, Science and Society, spring
Shaikh,A(1981), The Poverty of Algebra, The Value Controversy (Steedman,I and Sweezy,P & Others ed.), Verso
Shaikh,A(1984), The Transformation from Marx to Sraffa, Ricardo, Marx, Sraffa(Mandel,E & Freeman,A ed.), Verso.
Shaikh(1992), Values and Value Transfers: A Comment on Itoh, Radical Economics (Roberts,B & Feiner,S ed.), Kluwer Academic Pub.
Sraffa,P(1960), Production of Commodities by Means of Commodities, Cambridge at the University Press[박찬일 譯(1986), 『상품에 의한 상품의 생산』, 비봉]
Steedman,I(1977), Marx after Sraffa, NLB.
Steedman,I(1981), Ricardo, Marx, Sraffa, The Value Controversy (Steedman,I and Sweezy,P & Others ed.), Verso
Steedman,I.(1985), Heterogenous labor, money wage, and Marx`s theory, History of Political Economy, 17:4
Steedman,I(1991), The irrelevance of Marxian values, Marx and Modern Economic Analysis (G.A Cavale ed.), Edward Elgar.
Sweezy,P.(1956), The Theory of Capitalism, Monthly Review Press[이 훈 & 이재연 譯(1986), 『자본주의 발전이론』, 화다]
Sweezy,P(1981), Marxian Value Theory and Crises, The Value Controversy (Steedman,I and Sweezy,P & Others ed.), Verso
Uno.K(1980), Principles of Political Economy, Harvester Press
Weeks,J(1981), Capital and Exploitation, Arnold
Williams,M.(1992), Marxists on money, value and labor-power: a response to Cartelier, Cambridge Journal of Economics, 16.
Wolff,R.D., Roberts,B., & Callari,A.(1982), Marx`s (not Ricardo`s) `Transformation Problem`: A Radical Reconceptualization, History of Political Economics, 14:4
Wolff,R, Callari,A, & Roberts,B(1984a), A Marxian Alternative to the Traditional “Transformation Problem”, Review of Radical Political Economics, 16(2/3)
Wolff,R., Callari,A., Roberts,B.(1984b), Unsnarling the Tangle: a rejoinder, History of Political Economics, 16:3
Wolff,R.P(1984), Understanding Marx, Blackwell
Wolfson,M.(1984), Weaving a tangled web: the transformation of values into prices, History of Political Economics, 16:3
Wright,E.O(1981), The Value Theory and Social Research, The Value Controversy (Steedman,I and Sweezy,P & Others ed.), Verso
Wright,E.O(1981), Reconsideration, The Value Controversy (Steedman,I and Sweezy,P & Others ed.), Verso
Young,G.(1976), A note on Marx`s terminology, Science and Society, 1.

[일본문헌]
芦田文夫(1967), ｢ソ連における1920年代の價値論爭によせて｣, 『經濟硏究』, Vol.18 No.4
米川紀生(1969), ｢勞動と價値に關するイル-ビンの見解について｣, 『一橋論叢』, 第61卷 第5號
吉田 絃(1982), ｢社會的必要勞動と價値｣, 『硏究年譜‘經濟學’』, Vol.43 No.4
吉田 絃(1983), ｢抽象的人間勞動と價値｣, 『硏究年譜‘經濟學’』, Vol.45 No.3
正木八郞(1982), ｢マルクスの價値形態論と勞動の抽象化｣, 『經濟硏究』, Vol.33 No.1
正木八郞(1989), ｢マルクス價値論の再檢討(1)｣, 『經濟學雜誌』, 第90卷 第1號
正木八郞(1989), ｢マルクス價値論の再檢討(2)｣, 『經濟學雜誌』, 第90卷 第2號
種瀨 茂(1983), ｢<價値の實體>規定をめぐる論爭｣, 『資本論體系 第 2卷 貨幣.商品』, 有斐閣
海老塚明(1984), ｢貨幣と經濟學批判｣, 『一橋論叢』, 第91卷 第5號
植村博恭(1985), ｢‘勞動の還元’と抽象的人間勞動 - 歐米マルクス價値論論爭の展望｣, 『エコノミア』, 第84號
見田石介(1986), 『마르크스의 방법론』(김정로 역), 지양사
宮澤俊郞(1987), ｢價値形態と社會的勞動｣, 『一橋論叢』, 第98卷 第2號
小島 彰(1987), ｢抽象的人間勞動の特殊歷史的性格について｣, 『一橋論叢』, 第92卷 第2號
田島慶吾(1989), ｢價値槪念と辨證法的方法｣, 『一橋論叢』, 第101卷 第2號
梅澤直樹(1991), 『價値論のポテンシャル』, 昭和堂
大澤 健(1993), ｢‘抽象的人間勞動’の性格規定と‘商品論’解釋｣, 『硏究年譜‘經濟學’』,